Перейти к содержимому
TradingFormsБесплатные торговые документы и инструменты

EXW vs FOB: Who Pays What, and Which Quote Is Cheaper

· 5 мин чтения

EXW vs FOB: Who Pays What, and Which Quote Is Cheaper

The difference between EXW and FOB is where the seller's job ends. Under EXW (Ex Works) the seller just has the goods ready at its own door, and the buyer pays and carries the risk for everything from loading onward. Under FOB (Free On Board) the seller also clears export, trucks the goods to the port and gets them loaded on the ship, and risk passes once they're on board.

So an EXW quote is always lower than an FOB quote for the same goods, but it isn't cheaper. The buyer pays the gap, usually at a worse rate, in a country where they have no staff. Below is every line of that gap, a worked example, and when neither term is the right one.

EXW vs FOB: who pays for what

This is the Incoterms 2020 split, taken from our Incoterms chart. The rows where EXW and FOB differ are the ones you're paying for when you accept an EXW price.

Cost or task EXW FOB
Export packing and marking Seller Seller
Loading at the seller's premises Buyer Seller
Export customs clearance Buyer Seller
Transport to the port Buyer Seller
Terminal charges and loading at origin Buyer Seller
Ocean freight Buyer Buyer
Cargo insurance not required not required
Import clearance, duties and taxes Buyer Buyer

Four rows move. Everything from the ship onward is the same under both terms.

Where risk passes under EXW and FOB

Under EXW, risk passes when the goods are placed at the buyer's disposal at the named place, not loaded. If a forklift drops a pallet while your trucker is loading it at the factory, that's your loss.

Under FOB, risk passes when the goods are on board the vessel at the named port of shipment. A pallet dropped at the factory, crushed on the road or damaged in the terminal yard is still the seller's problem.

Neither term makes anyone insure the cargo. If you buy on EXW or FOB, arrange your own cargo insurance from the point where risk becomes yours.

Is EXW or FOB cheaper? A worked example

Say a factory in Ningbo quotes two prices for 600 cartons of kitchenware, one 40 foot container:

  • EXW Ningbo factory: $18,400
  • FOB Ningbo port: $19,150

The $750 gap is the seller's estimate for the four rows above: trucking to the port, the export declaration, origin terminal charges and loading. On EXW, your freight forwarder has to buy those same services. If the forwarder's origin charges come to $900, the EXW deal costs you $150 more than FOB, plus the job of managing a pickup on the other side of the world.

The numbers here are an example, not market rates. The method is what matters:

  1. Ask the supplier for both EXW and FOB prices on the same quote.
  2. Ask your forwarder for an origin charges quote on the EXW pickup.
  3. Compare EXW + forwarder origin charges against FOB.
  4. Then add the freight and duties, which are the same either way, in a landed cost calculator to see your real cost per unit.

That is why FOB often comes out ahead on a first order: the supplier books trucks and customs brokers at local rates, and your forwarder adds its own margin on top of theirs.

The export clearance problem with EXW

EXW makes the buyer responsible for export clearance, and that's where it often goes wrong. In many countries only a local registered business can file the export declaration, so a foreign buyer can't legally do it. In practice the seller files it anyway, which quietly turns the deal into something that isn't EXW.

For US exports, a sale where the foreign buyer's agent arranges the shipment is a routed export transaction. The US seller still has to give the forwarder the information for the Electronic Export Information filing in AES (U.S. Census Bureau, Foreign Trade Regulations). So even on EXW, a US exporter can't simply walk away once the truck leaves.

This is why the ICC notes that EXW suits domestic trade better than exports.

When to use FCA instead of EXW or FOB

Use FCA (Free Carrier) when the goods ship in a container, or when you like the idea of EXW but want the seller to load and clear export. We ran our Incoterms chooser through the common cases:

Your situation Chooser result
Container, buyer pays freight, goods handed to buyer's carrier export cleared FCA
Container, buyer collects at seller's door and clears export EXW
Bulk cargo, buyer pays freight, goods on board the ship FOB
Bulk cargo, buyer pays freight, goods alongside the ship FAS

FOB was written for cargo loaded straight onto a ship, like grain or steel coils. A container is handed to the terminal days before it's loaded, so under FOB the seller carries risk for a box it no longer controls. FCA moves the handover to the terminal or the seller's dock, which matches what actually happens. That's why the ICC recommends FCA for container shipments, even though most suppliers still quote FOB out of habit.

Our honest view: if a supplier quotes FOB on container cargo, you don't need to fight it on a first order. The term is understood everywhere. Just know that the risk point is fuzzy, and insure from the factory.

Which documents change between EXW and FOB?

The commercial invoice and the bill of lading look almost the same. What changes is the Incoterms line and the place named after it:

  • EXW names the seller's address: "EXW 88 Industrial Road, Ningbo, Incoterms 2020".
  • FOB names the port: "FOB Ningbo, Incoterms 2020".

Always write the rule, the named place and "Incoterms 2020" together. "FOB China" is too vague to settle a dispute. Our commercial invoice generator and proforma invoice generator have an Incoterms field for exactly this.

Quick checklist before you accept a quote

  • Is it EXW, FCA or FOB, and what's the exact named place?
  • If EXW, who files the export declaration, and does your forwarder have an origin agent?
  • Does the FOB price include terminal handling at origin, or will it be billed again?
  • Who insures the goods, and from where?
  • Is the cargo containerised? Then ask for FCA.

Still not sure? Open the full rules for EXW and FOB, or let the chooser pick the term in a few clicks.

Frequently asked questions

What is the main difference between EXW and FOB?

Under EXW the seller only makes the goods ready at its own premises, and the buyer handles loading, export clearance and everything after. Under FOB the seller also clears export and delivers the goods on board the ship at the named port.

Is EXW cheaper than FOB?

The EXW price is always lower, but the total is often not. The buyer must pay origin trucking, export clearance and terminal charges, usually at higher rates than the supplier gets locally. Compare EXW plus your forwarder's origin charges with the FOB price.

Who pays export duties under EXW and FOB?

Under EXW the buyer is responsible for export clearance and any export duties. Under FOB the seller is. Import duties and taxes are the buyer's under both terms.

Can FOB be used for air freight or containers?

FOB is meant for sea and inland waterway transport only, so it does not fit air freight. It is widely used for containers, but the ICC recommends FCA for container cargo because the box is handed over at the terminal before it is loaded.

Does EXW include loading the truck?

No. Under EXW the buyer is responsible for loading at the seller's premises, even though the seller often does it in practice. If you want the seller to load and clear export, use FCA at the seller's premises.